Helping Music Artists earn a great living
—without selling their soul.
___________________
“When you make music or write or create, it's really your job to have mind-blowing, irresponsible, condomless sex with whatever idea it is you're writing about at the time.”
― Lady Gaga
In This Issue... 23 pages (about 34ish minutes to read) You'll Get...
• TrueFans Recommends — Howie Singer Understanding What Technology Does to Music... and What Happens Next
• Your BIZ — Is the Music Business Collapsing?
• in partnership with Ted Gioia the Honest-Broker
• Greatest Music Artist of All Time — Gloria Jones: The Woman Behind the Music
• TrueFans Feature — Music Is Not a Democracy
• P.S. from PS — and It's All Connected
Here’s the playlist
Every time a new technology arrives, somebody announces that the music business will never be the same. And they're usually right. But is that good news or bad news for Music Artists?
This week's recommendation comes from someone who's spent years exploring that very question. His work offers something especially valuable in an industry obsessed with predicting the future: a better understanding of the past.
• TrueFans Recommends — Howie Singer Understanding What Technology Does to Music... and What Happens Next
Want to understand where the music business is going?
Start by looking at where it's been.
From the phonograph to radio, from vinyl to CDs, from downloads to streaming, technology has repeatedly changed how music is created, distributed, discovered, experienced and paid for.
And each revolution has produced winners, losers, unexpected opportunities, and plenty of people convinced that music as we know it is finished.
Enter Howie Singer.
A music industry veteran, technology strategist, author and educator, Singer brings a particularly useful perspective to the conversation. Rather than treating every new technology as either a miracle or a catastrophe, he examines what actually happens when technological innovation meets the business of music.
His book, Key Changes: The Ten Times Technology Transformed the Music Industry, coauthored with Bill Rosenblatt, explores ten major technological turning points and their consequences for Music Artists, record companies, audiences and the industry itself.
It's an important reminder that today's disruption isn't the first.
And it certainly won't be the last.
History Doesn't Repeat Itself. But Music Technology Has a Rhythm.
Consider what happened when recorded music first became commercially viable. Or when radio made music available to millions of listeners without requiring them to purchase a record. Or when digital downloads and streaming challenged the economics of physical recordings.
Each innovation changed more than the technology.
It changed relationships, expectations, business models and the ways Music Artists could reach their audiences.
That's the real value of Singer's work.
He helps us see the patterns beneath the headlines.
And those patterns matter because independent Music Artists today are facing another extraordinary period of change, driven by artificial intelligence, evolving streaming economics, new discovery platforms and increasingly direct relationships between artists and their audiences.
Two Places to Begin
1. Key Changes: The Ten Times Technology Transformed the Music Industry
A fascinating exploration of the inventions and innovations that reshaped the music business — and the lessons those changes offer for understanding what's happening now.
2. Howie Singer's Key Changes Newsletter
For readers who want to keep exploring the intersection of music, technology and business, Singer's ongoing commentary provides another opportunity to examine the forces shaping the industry's future.
Why We Recommend It
Because understanding technology isn't simply about knowing how to use the latest tools.
It's about understanding what those tools change. Who benefits? Who gets left behind? What new opportunities emerge? And what must Music Artists do differently to build sustainable careers?
At TrueFans, we believe technology should help Music Artists develop stronger relationships with the people who love their music — not become another obstacle standing between them.
Howie Singer's work helps put those possibilities into perspective.
The future of music will certainly involve new technology.
The more important question is what Music Artists
choose to do with it.
Explore: Key Changes — Official Website
What if the biggest crisis in the music business turns out to be one of the greatest opportunities independent music artists have ever had?
Music historian, author, and industry observer Ted Gioia has just published a blistering assessment of the major record labels and the seven mistakes he believes are bringing them to their knees.
It's a fascinating read. And for independent artists, it may be something even more important: a wake-up call. And a reason for optimism.
• Your BIZ—Is the Music Business Collapsing?
Or is the OLD music business collapsing
— and something better taking its place?
The music business is in trouble. The music? Not so much.
That's the distinction at the heart of Ted Gioia's October 27 article, Is the Music Business Collapsing?, published in his newsletter The Honest Broker.
Gioia describes a music industry in which major record labels are struggling to justify their business models, streaming has fundamentally changed the economics of recorded music, and the companies that once controlled nearly every aspect of an artist's career are discovering that their traditional advantages are disappearing.
He identifies seven mistakes behind the trouble. And while his analysis is aimed primarily at the major labels, we think there's something extraordinarily valuable here for every independent music artist.
Because...
... every mistake the old music business made contains a lesson about how to build a better music business of your own.
1. They stopped developing talent.
Once upon a time, record labels invested in artists. Not simply songs that might become hits, but people who might become extraordinary musicians, performers, and songwriters over time.
Artist development meant patience. It meant taking chances. It meant allowing musicians to find their voices, make mistakes, improve their craft, and sometimes release several albums before achieving commercial success.
That kind of investment became increasingly difficult to justify in an industry obsessed with immediate results.
Your BIZ Lesson: Don't confuse popularity with progress.
An artist's career isn't built by a single viral moment. It's built by becoming better at making music, performing it, communicating its value, and developing an audience that wants to come along for the journey.
A hundred fans who discover you today and are still listening five years from now may be worth more than thousands who encounter one song and disappear tomorrow.
Invest in your development. Give yourself permission to grow. And give your audience the opportunity to grow with you.
2. They invested in yesterday instead of tomorrow.
Gioia points to the enormous sums spent acquiring catalogs of established songs and artists.
There's nothing wrong with great music from the past. We celebrate it every week in the AMP. But buying yesterday's successes isn't the same thing as creating tomorrow's. The music business needs new voices, new songs, new ideas, and new artists who have something meaningful to say.
When financial investment in existing intellectual property becomes more attractive than investment in living, developing musicians, something important has gone missing.
Your BIZ Lesson: Your greatest asset isn't your catalog. It's your capacity to keep creating.
Yes, your songs have value. Your recordings have value. But so does your next song. Your next performance. Your next conversation with someone who loves what you do. A music career is a living, evolving relationship between an artist and an audience. Don't allow the business of managing what you've already created to crowd out the joy and necessity of creating what's next.
3. They gave away the relationship with the listener.
This may be the most important mistake of all.
The major labels embraced streaming platforms as the future of music distribution. But in the process, they allowed those platforms to become the primary relationship holders between music and the people listening to it.
Think about that.
The label owns or controls the recording. The artist creates the music. But the platform often knows who listens, what they like, where they are, and how to reach them.
The artist may receive a stream count without ever knowing who the listener is. And that changes everything.
Your BIZ Lesson: A listener is not necessarily a fan. And a fan you cannot reach is a relationship you haven't yet built.
Streaming is a wonderful discovery tool. Use it. Celebrate it. But don't confuse discovery with connection.
Give people a reason — and an easy way — to move from listening to knowing you. Invite them to your website, your mailing list, your performances, your community.
Ask them questions. Listen to their answers. Let them know there's a real person behind the music.
Because...
... the most valuable thing you can build isn't a number on a streaming dashboard. It's a relationship with another human being.
4. They treated artists as suppliers instead of partners.
Gioia argues that the industry missed opportunities to create more equitable relationships with musicians, including alternative approaches to streaming.
The underlying problem is familiar. When the people creating the value have too little influence over how that value is distributed, trust begins to disappear. And without trust, partnership becomes difficult.
This is particularly important in music, where the product isn't simply a manufactured object. It's somebody's imagination, talent, experience, effort, and often a piece of their heart.
Your BIZ Lesson: Build partnerships, not dependencies.
Whether you're working with a manager, producer, venue owner, promoter, distributor, or another artist, ask yourself: Is this relationship helping both of us succeed? Do we understand each other's goals? Are we communicating? Are we creating value together?
And here's another partnership that's too often overlooked: the one between an artist and the people who support their music.
TrueFans aren't merely customers. They're people who can become advocates, collaborators, ambassadors, and an essential part of your success.
Treat them accordingly.
5. They haven't figured out what to do about AI.
Artificial intelligence is already changing how music is created, distributed, discovered, and consumed. Gioia criticizes the industry's lack of a coherent response. The major labels face questions about rights, compensation, competition, and the possibility of enormous volumes of AI-generated music entering the marketplace.
Those are serious questions. And they deserve serious answers.
But while the industry debates, technology keeps moving.
Your BIZ Lesson: Don't wait for the music industry to decide your future.
Learn what AI can do for you. Not necessarily to write your songs or replace your creative voice, but to help with the business work that can consume so much of an independent artist's time. Research. Planning. Promotion. Audience communication. Organizing information. Developing ideas. Understanding what works and what doesn't.
The possibilities are considerable.
And there's a paradox worth considering. As technology makes it easier to produce more music...
...the human connection between an artist and an audience may become more valuable, not less.
People can listen to a recording. But they can also care about the person who made it.
That's something worth building on.
6. They allowed financial thinking to overwhelm creative thinking.
Of course, a music business needs to make money. Artists need to earn a living. Record labels need revenue. Investors expect returns.
But Gioia's criticism goes deeper than that.
When lawyers, accountants, and financial strategists become more influential than the people who understand music and musicians, the organization risks losing sight of what made it valuable in the first place.
A balance sheet can tell you what a company owns. It cannot tell you which unknown songwriter will move an audience to tears.
A spreadsheet can measure yesterday's revenue. It cannot reliably predict tomorrow's masterpiece.
Your BIZ Lesson: Learn the business without allowing the business to swallow the music.
Know your numbers. Understand your costs. Develop multiple sources of income. Make thoughtful decisions about where you invest your time and money.
But remember why you're doing all of this.
Your business exists to support your music and your life.
Not the other way around.
And while money is essential, it isn't the only measure of success. Creative satisfaction, independence, community, and the freedom to continue making music matter, too.
The goal is to build a business that makes more of those things possible.
7. They forgot to love the music.
This may be Gioia's most devastating criticism.
The music industry became so preoccupied with the machinery of making money from music that it began losing touch with the music itself.
And perhaps that's the inevitable danger when an industry becomes more interested in managing assets than nurturing artists.
Music isn't simply content. It isn't merely a collection of intellectual property rights, streams, playlists, and licensing opportunities.
It's something people make because they have something to express. And something other people listen to because it makes them feel, remember, imagine, celebrate, grieve, hope, dance, or simply feel less alone.
That's where the value begins.
Your BIZ Lesson: Never forget why people fell in love with your music — or why you fell in love with making it.
The songs matter. The performances matter. The experiences you create matter.
And the people on the receiving end of all that creativity matter enormously. When somebody tells you your music helped them through a difficult time, made their wedding unforgettable, or reminded them of someone they loved, that's not a marketing metric.
That's the reason music matters.
And it may also be the strongest foundation upon which to build a lasting career.
So, is the music business collapsing?
Maybe parts of it are.
But perhaps the more interesting question is:
What kind of music business is taking its place?
For decades, the traditional model was built around controlling access. The labels controlled recording, distribution, promotion, and much of the connection between artists and audiences.
Today, an independent artist can record a song, release it worldwide, find listeners, communicate directly with them, sell music and merchandise, perform live, and build a community without waiting for somebody else's permission.
That's extraordinary.
But access alone isn't enough.
A million streams won't necessarily pay the rent. Thousands of social media followers won't necessarily buy a ticket. And an algorithm that introduces your music to somebody today may never introduce you to that person again.
Which is why we believe the most important opportunity for independent music artists isn't simply reaching more people.
It's building stronger relationships with the people you reach.
That's the thinking behind TrueFans.
Technology can help you discover an audience. But relationships turn that audience into people who care about you, support you, share your music, attend your performances, and want to be part of your future.
It doesn't begin with ten thousand strangers.
It can begin with ten people who genuinely love what you do.
Learn their names. Thank them. Talk with them. Give them reasons to stay connected. Invite them to participate in your journey.
Then do it again.
And again.
Because a sustainable music career doesn't have to depend on winning the attention lottery every time you release a song.
It can grow from a foundation of people who are already listening
— and who want to keep listening.
Ted Gioia has given the major music companies seven serious reasons to reconsider the way they do business.
He's also given independent artists seven opportunities to do things differently.
And maybe that's the real story.
The old music business may be losing its way.
You don't have to lose yours.
You have something the major labels can't manufacture, acquire, or put on a balance sheet.
You have the opportunity to create a genuine human relationship with every person who loves your music.
Start there.
And keep going.
__________
Read Ted Gioia's Original Article
Is the Music Business Collapsing? — The Honest Broker
The major labels made seven big mistakes. Independent artists have seven opportunities to learn from them.
This version gives each of Ted's seven criticisms its own Your BIZ Lesson, while keeping our central argument intact: the future belongs to artists who build relationships, not merely audiences.
Source: Ted Gioia, The Honest Broker, October 27, 2026. His seven criticisms are summarized; the TrueFans interpretation and artist recommendations are our own.
by Ted Gioia
• in partnership with Ted Gioia the Honest-Broker
Ted Gioia is one of the world’s foremost authorities on music, celebrated for his deep understanding, thought-provoking insights, and ability to uncover the stories behind the songs that shape our lives. A prolific writer, historian, and critic, Ted has authored eleven books, including the widely acclaimed The History of Jazz, now in its third edition and considered a definitive work in the field.
His essays and reviews explore a vast array of musical genres, blending scholarship with a storyteller’s flair. Ted’s keen analyses and reflections have appeared in The Atlantic, The New York Times, and Los Angeles Review of Books, among other prestigious publications. Whether he’s writing about jazz, classical, rock, or folk traditions, Ted’s voice resonates with both seasoned musicians and casual music lovers alike.
Beyond the page, Ted Gioia is a champion of independent music and creative expression. His popular Substack newsletter, The Honest Broker, is a must-read for those seeking fresh perspectives on music and culture, offering an eclectic mix of reviews, commentary, and curated playlists.
In a world where music often risks being reduced to background noise, Ted Gioia reminds us of its transformative power, its ability to inspire, and its role as a central thread in the fabric of human history.
To learn more about Ted Gioia and his work, visit tedgioia.com. And on substack at the Honest-Broker.
You know the song. You've almost certainly heard it, danced to it, perhaps even sung along. But do you know the woman who sang it first?
Before Soft Cell made “Tainted Love” an international sensation, Gloria Jones recorded a soul-powered original that became a Northern Soul anthem. And that's only the beginning. Motown songwriter, gospel singer, collaborator with some of music's greatest names, and a woman whose extraordinary life has encompassed love, loss, reinvention, and giving back.
This week's Greatest Music Artists of All Time celebrates an artist whose fingerprints are all over music history — even if her name isn't.
• Greatest Music Artist of All Time — Gloria Jones: The Woman Behind the Music
Some artists become famous for the music they make.
Others make music that becomes famous without them.
Gloria Jones has done both. Although the second part of that story has received considerably more attention than the first.

Born in Cincinnati in 1945 and raised in Los Angeles, Gloria grew up in the church, where gospel music became the foundation of a voice that could soar, plead, testify, and command attention. As a teenager she helped form the COGIC Singers, alongside talents including Billy Preston and Andraé Crouch.
It was an extraordinary musical education.
And she was only getting started.
The Song That Wouldn't Go Away
In 1964, songwriter and producer Ed Cobb brought a young Gloria a song called Tainted Love.
She wasn't quite sure what to make of it. The very word tainted bothered her. She was young, church-raised, and uncertain what her parents might think. But she agreed to sing it — and brought her own musical instincts to the recording.
Her performance was raw, urgent, rhythmic, and gloriously soulful. Yet commercially, it went almost nowhere.
Then something remarkable happened.
Across the Atlantic, Britain's Northern Soul movement was discovering overlooked American soul records and turning them into dance-floor treasures.
Gloria's Tainted Love became one of
the movement's defining anthems.
Years later, an electronic duo called Soft Cell heard the song, reimagined it with synthesizers, and released their version in 1981.
The result? An international phenomenon.
Millions knew the song. Far fewer knew the woman who had first given it a voice.
“I loved it so much, and we wanted an interesting song for an encore number in our show.”
— Marc Almond, Soft Cell
And here's an important distinction: Gloria didn't write Tainted Love. Ed Cobb did. But her interpretation helped give the song the life that made everything afterward possible.
The Motown Years: Behind the Hits
Gloria wasn't merely a singer waiting for her own breakthrough. She was helping create breakthroughs for other artists.
At Motown, working with songwriter Pam Sawyer, she co-wrote If I Were Your Woman, a magnificent recording by Gladys Knight & the Pips that became one of the group's signature songs and earned a Grammy nomination.
She also co-wrote My Mistake (Was to Love You) for Diana Ross and Marvin Gaye, and contributed to the songwriting world surrounding other Motown stars.
Think about that for a moment.
While audiences were falling in love with the voices of celebrated performers, Gloria Jones was helping supply the songs that made those voices unforgettable.
Singer. Songwriter. Collaborator.
A musician's musician.
Enter Marc Bolan
Then came another chapter — and another musical universe.
In the 1970s, Gloria joined T. Rex, performing keyboards and backing vocals with British glam-rock superstar Marc Bolan. Their professional collaboration became a personal relationship, and together they had a son, Rolan.
It was a fascinating pairing: the flamboyant British rock star and the gospel-rooted American soul singer. Gloria's musical sensibilities contributed to the changing sound of Bolan's later work, while he encouraged her to record her own material.
“He wanted me to express and to bring that power out in my voice.”
— Gloria Jones, recalling Marc Bolan
Her album Vixen captured some of that creative partnership.
But in September 1977, tragedy struck. Gloria was driving when their car crashed in London, killing Bolan at just 29.
It was a devastating loss, made more painful by the scrutiny that followed.
For many artists, such an event might have become the final defining chapter.
For Gloria, it was not.
A Legacy Bigger Than Records
In the decades that followed, Gloria's life took her beyond the recording studio and into humanitarian work.
Together with her son Rolan, she established the Marc Bolan School of Music and Film in Sierra Leone, creating opportunities for young people through music and education.
It is perhaps the most moving part of her story.
A woman whose early career had been shaped by gospel music and the joy of singing was now helping other young people discover what music might make possible in their own lives.
Not simply preserving a musical legacy.
Extending it.
The Music That Matters
Tainted Love (1964) — The original. Play this one beside Soft Cell's version and hear how one song can become two entirely different musical experiences.
Heartbeat — Another powerful early recording that reveals Gloria's unmistakable vocal fire.
If I Were Your Woman — Gladys Knight & the Pips — Gloria as songwriter. A reminder that an artist's greatest contributions aren't always made behind a microphone.
My Mistake (Was to Love You) — Diana Ross & Marvin Gaye — Another chapter in her Motown songwriting legacy.
Tainted Love — from Vixen — Gloria revisiting the song that refused to leave her life.
Share My Love — An invitation to explore Gloria as a solo artist, beyond the record for which she's best known.
The Voices of Appreciation
“I was fascinated that it was originally by Gloria Jones...”
— Marc Almond, Soft Cell
“An astounding talent and a wonderful lady, both then and now.”
— BP Fallon, music publicist and broadcaster
“Your voice on those first recordings is stunning when you hear it.”
— Michael Barnes, KCRW
“Someone who had an incredible career.”
— Novena Carmel, KCRW
“The truly amazing artist that is Gloria Jones.”
— Michael Barnes, KCRW
And perhaps the most touching words of all come from Gloria herself, remembering how Marc Bolan spoke about her original recording:
“Which is why he called me ‘The’ Gloria Jones.”
The Greatest Music Artist?
We sometimes measure greatness by chart positions, record sales, awards, and headlines. And certainly those things have their place.
But what about influence? What about the song that changes another artist's career? The voice that helps shape another artist's sound? The music that crosses an ocean and finds an audience its creator never imagined?
And what about the lives touched long after the records stop spinning?
Gloria Jones offers a compelling answer.
The greatest music artists aren't always the ones whose names we remember. Sometimes they're the ones whose music we never forget.
Gloria Jones.
Now you know her name.
Listen & Discover
The internet was supposed to revolutionize the music business. And it did. The gatekeepers were gone. The doors were open. Every Music Artist could reach a worldwide audience. But somewhere between that extraordinary promise and today's streaming economy, something went wrong.
Music industry analyst Mark Mulligan has identified a fascinating paradox: Making music available to everybody hasn't necessarily made earning a living any easier for anybody. His analysis raises some uncomfortable questions — and points toward a future we at TrueFans believe is already taking shape.
• TrueFans Feature — Music Is Not a Democracy
Everybody Can Make Music.
Everybody Can Be Heard.
But Who Gets Paid?
The music industry opened its doors to everybody. Then discovered that opening the doors wasn't the same as opening the cash register.
Once upon a time, if you wanted to make a living as a recording artist, you needed someone to say YES. A record company executive. A radio programmer. A music publisher. A promoter. Somebody with the authority — and the resources — to give your music a chance.
These were the gatekeepers. They decided who got heard, who got promoted, who got distributed, and, more often than not, who got paid.
Then along came the internet.
And everything changed.
Or did it?
The Revolution That Wasn't Quite What We Expected
In his provocative essay, The Problem with Democratization, music industry analyst MIDiA's Mark Mulligan explores one of the great contradictions of the modern entertainment business.
The internet promised to eliminate gatekeepers. Instead, it largely replaced human gatekeepers with technological ones.
Record companies and publishers had traditionally operated through selection. They chose what to release, promote and distribute. Their business depended, in part, on deciding what deserved their limited resources.
Digital platforms approached the problem differently.
Their advantage came from scale. More music. More creators. More content. More listeners. More engagement. The platforms didn't need to decide which few thousand artists deserved a chance. They could accommodate millions.
For independent Music Artists, this was extraordinary.
No record deal required. No permission necessary. No expensive physical distribution network.
Record your music. Upload it. Make it available to the world.
Welcome to the democratization of music!
Except there was a catch.
Actually, several.
When Everybody Has a Seat at the Table
Mulligan describes the consequences of what he calls nichification — the fragmentation of enormous audiences into countless smaller communities with increasingly specialized interests.
Culturally, this is wonderful.
Music lovers can discover virtually any genre, subgenre, musical tradition or experimental sound imaginable. Artists who might never have survived the traditional record-company selection process can find listeners who genuinely appreciate their work.
But economically?
That's another story.
The platforms benefit from aggregating all those niches into enormous audiences.
Individual artists, however, must figure out how to earn enough money from their particular little corner of that enormous marketplace.
Mulligan cites music economist Will Page's observation that there are simply too many mouths to feed at the table.
And there's the paradox.
The system can become enormously successful without making the individual Music Artists who supply it financially successful.
The platforms have scale.
The artists have competition.
And attention, however plentiful it may appear, doesn't automatically pay the rent.
Twenty Thousand Albums Versus Millions of Streams
Here's where Mulligan's argument becomes particularly revealing.
He offers a comparison between the economics of an independent band thirty years ago and those of a similar artist working in today's streaming economy.
Back then, an independent band selling 20,000 albums could, in his example, earn approximately $60,000 after deductions by the label and retailers.
Twenty thousand buyers. Sixty thousand dollars.
To generate comparable revenue through streaming today, Mulligan estimates that the band would need seven times as many people to listen to the album three times each. That's approximately 140,000 listeners, each playing the entire album three times.
And even that comparison depends on the economics of the particular streaming arrangement, the music being played, and how revenue is distributed.
His point isn't that every independent band once earned a comfortable living. Nor that every streaming artist is struggling. It's that...
... access to an audience and the ability to earn meaningful income from that audience are two very different things.
An artist can reach more listeners than ever before and still struggle financially.
That's not the revolution most musicians imagined.
The New Gatekeepers
And what happened to those supposedly eliminated gatekeepers?
They never really disappeared.
They changed.
Today, algorithms influence what listeners discover, what appears in recommendations, what gets promoted, and what becomes visible — or invisible — in an almost limitless ocean of music. The difference is that the traditional gatekeepers generally selected a relatively small number of artists to support.
The digital platforms can accommodate virtually everybody, while their recommendation systems influence who receives attention.
The opportunity to participate has been democratized.
The opportunity to be discovered — and financially rewarded
— remains decidedly unequal.
Which brings us to what may be Mulligan's most important observation.
The Big Platform, Small Audience Solution
Mulligan suggests that Music Artists need to learn to use two very different economic models together.
Use scale to find your audience.
Use niche to monetise it.
In other words, Spotify, YouTube, TikTok, Instagram and other enormous platforms can be extraordinarily useful for introducing your music to people who have never heard it.
They're discovery engines.
And discovery matters.
But once somebody discovers your music, what happens next?
Do they listen once and disappear?
Do they follow you but never hear from you again?
Do they become one more anonymous statistic in a dashboard full of streams, views, likes and impressions?
Or does something more meaningful begin?
A relationship.
A connection.
A conversation.
Mulligan points to innovations such as Patreon memberships, SoundCloud's fan-powered royalties and alternative streaming payment models as attempts to address the problem.
He doesn't claim that one solution has emerged victorious.
In fact, he suggests the absence of one universal solution may be precisely the point. Different artists, audiences and communities may require different ways of creating and exchanging value.
His conclusion is beautifully simple:
"The future of monetizing niche will of course be niche."
From Audience to Community. From Listeners to TrueFans.
This is where Mulligan's analysis intersects with something we've been exploring at the TrueFans AMP™ for years.
The fundamental challenge for an independent Music Artist isn't simply finding people willing to listen.
It's developing relationships with people who care enough to keep listening—and eventually participate in the artist's musical life.
Think about the difference.
A listener hears your song.
A fan comes back to hear another.
A more engaged fan tells a friend, attends a show, signs up for your updates or buys your music.
And a TrueFan?
A TrueFan becomes an active participant in your success. Someone who supports you, recommends you, celebrates your achievements and wants to be part of what you're creating.
Not every listener will become a TrueFan.
Not every TrueFan will contribute financially in the same way.
And no particular number of fans guarantees a particular income.
But the more genuine, mutually rewarding relationships an artist develops, the more opportunities there are to build a sustainable career beyond the unpredictable economics of streaming.
It's not simply about how many people hear your music.
It's about what happens between you and those people
after they hear it.
A Different Way to Measure Success
Consider two independent Music Artists.
One has 100,000 monthly listeners on Spotify but no direct means of communicating with most of them.
The other has 5,000 monthly listeners, but also a community of several hundred people who regularly respond to messages, attend performances, recommend the music and support new releases.
Which artist has the stronger business?
We can't know from those numbers alone.
But we can ask a better question.
Which artist has developed relationships that can survive a change in algorithms, a shift in platform popularity, or the disappearance of a particular promotional opportunity?
And which artist knows the people who are making their musical career possible?
That's a different way of thinking about success.
Not abandoning the numbers.
Understanding what the numbers actually mean.
The Future Is Personal
The great irony of the digital music revolution may be that the technology enabling Music Artists to reach billions of people has made genuine, individual human relationships more valuable than ever.
Algorithms can recommend a song.
Platforms can distribute it.
Artificial intelligence can help create, organise, analyse and promote music.
But none of those things, by itself, creates the experience of being personally appreciated by an artist whose music has touched your life.
That's something human.
Something personal.
And something worth cultivating.
Mark Mulligan has identified a fundamental economic challenge facing independent Music Artists. His analysis suggests that the answer won't necessarily come from making the giant platforms even bigger or hoping that one new payment model will solve everything.
It may come from creating smaller, stronger, more economically meaningful relationships within the enormous audiences those platforms make possible.
At TrueFans, we believe that's not merely a promising business strategy.
It's a better way to build a musical life.
Because the future of music may be global.
But the future of a Music Artist's livelihood is personal.
And perhaps the greatest opportunity of all isn't reaching another million strangers.
It's turning more of the listeners you already have into people who know you, appreciate you, and want to help you succeed.
One listener.
One conversation.
One TrueFan at a time.
__________
Source and inspiration: Mark Mulligan, "The Problem with Democratisation," Letter from the MD. The historical album-sales and streaming comparison is drawn from Mulligan's analysis and should be understood as an illustrative example rather than a universal royalty calculation.Tap the title to read Mark's original.
What do Gloria Jones, Ted Gioia, and Mark Mulligan have in common? At first glance, perhaps not much. One has a remarkable place in music history. The others are asking important questions about music's present and future. But look a little closer and a common thread emerges.
Paul Saunders has been thinking about that thread — and about something the music business can never afford to lose.
• P.S. from PS — and It's All Connected
Sometimes I wonder whether we've made the music business far more complicated than it needs to be.
Look at the stories we've been exploring.
Gloria Jones reminds us that the person who starts something extraordinary isn't necessarily the person who gets the recognition. A song can travel around the world, touch millions of lives, and become part of music history while the artist who first gave it life remains comparatively unknown.
Ted Gioia challenges us to think about what's happening to music in a world increasingly dominated by technology, platforms, algorithms, and the endless pursuit of attention.
And Mark Mulligan points to one of the great ironies of the digital music revolution:
Everybody can make music available to the world, but that doesn't mean everybody gets heard. And it certainly doesn't mean everybody gets paid.
Three different perspectives. Three different stories.
But I keep coming back to the same thing.
It's all connected.
Music is created by people. Performed by people. Discovered, shared, loved, remembered, and supported by people. And somewhere along the way, we've become so fascinated by the machinery of the music business that we sometimes forget the people it's supposed to serve.
We count streams. Followers. Views. Likes. Impressions.
And, yes, those numbers matter.
But a million streams can't tell you what a song meant to the person who played it when they needed it most.
A thousand followers can't tell you how many
would cross town to see you perform.
And an algorithm can't tell you what happens when a Music Artist looks someone in the eye, says thank you, and means it.
That's where something extraordinary begins.
A listener becomes a fan. A fan becomes a supporter. A supporter becomes someone who tells a friend, buys a ticket, shares a song, or helps an artist keep making music.
Not because an algorithm told them to.
Because they care.
I've always believed that the future of music belongs to Music Artists and the people who love their music.
Technology can help bring them together. It can make those connections easier, faster, and more far-reaching than anything previous generations could have imagined.
But technology isn't the relationship.
People are.
So here's my thought for this week.
Use the platforms. Embrace the technology. Take advantage of every opportunity to introduce your music to somebody new. But don't get so busy reaching the world that you forget to connect with the people you've already reached.
Because in the end, the music business isn't really about streams, algorithms, or platforms.
It's about people.
And people connecting with people.
It's all connected.

Thanks for reading. Give us your feedback.
And PLEASE, if you've got any Music Artist friends, pass the TrueFans AMP™ on, because... It’s Time... for a Change. Big Time. Past Time...
